Best Shaving Soap: My Top 5 Choices and a Detailed Guide


Well, hello! Good to see you here today! If you’ve bumped into this article of mine, you are probably searching the Best Shaving Soap for you that’d take all the hassles of nicks, bruises, and skin burns away.

Shaving is to be enjoyed! Yes, you heard me right. Even a mundane task like shaving can be enjoyed if you have the right tools nearby. One of them has to be the shaving soap.

Why? Well, it has to be the feeling.

The feeling you get while heating up the soap and whipping it with a soft brush is “Classy.” The feel it gives off when rubbing the creamy soap against your facial hair is paralleled by nothing!

Of course, there is the fact that these things are made using natural elements and not the chemical goops of the modern era. These are super-friendly to your skin as well.


Good! I’ll be handing out a list of Top 5 Soaps for Shaving for the enthusiasts with my reasoning behind the selection. I’ve also explained why I preferred soap over gel or cream in this article. Let’s dive in!

The Best Shaving Soap Contenders in My Book

Shaving soaps seldom miss the mark when it comes to quality and performance. It is hard as it is to decide the best among the ranks in terms of performance alone. Plus, you have to consider price, the size, scent and skin benefits as well. That is why, instead of selecting just one, I went on to compile top 5 shaving soap choices onto a list. Let us have a look!

1. Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap

Henry-Cavendish-Himalaya-Shaving-SoapShaving is a matter of luxury and comfort for any man. The Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap is one such product which helps us to accomplish this business with precision.

It is not a hunch that you get on the internet. With me, it is raw experience and one and a half years’ worth of experience using this thing firsthand.

The ingredients used to prepare this easily make it one of the most sought after varieties if not the best shaving soap. This product helps to lubricate the razor so that you get a slick, cushioned and frictionless shave. It contains a high glycerin content that provides extreme mildness and silky lather.

Unlike most shaving gels and creams, the lather is long lasting and does not dry out. One of the key ingredients in this brand is Shea Butter which does a lot of things while you shave.

The Butter makes skin smooth, removes oiliness, reduces irritation, moisturizes and revitalizes your skin – all at the same time. Cool, ain’t it?

Wait, there’s more!

Along with Shea Butter, the Henry Cavendish shaving soap also contains soy extracts. Soy extracts help to condition the skin to make it soft. A good amount of glycerin, coconut oil, and castor oil have been used in the soap which also aid in conditioning your skin providing silky soft results.

Before you jump the gun, no artificial fragrance is present in the soap. Instead, it has a natural mild scent. This minimal light scent feels fresh and pleasant, even ladies seem to like it. Yup, Henry Cavendish Himalaya Shaving Soap is suitable for the ladies to use as well!

It does not contain any harsh ingredients that might cause irritation. For best results, soak the soap in warm water for 2-3 minutes and then swirl a wet brush over it. This method helps to build up a thick lather in little time.

  • It is made from natural ingredients unlike many of the shaving soaps out there.
  • Unlike other shaving soaps, this one doesn’t cause irritations due to continuous using.
  • Shea butter does a good job of smoothening the skin for you.
  • The scent of this shaving soap last longer than most of its competitors but it is very minimal.
  • Ladies can also use this shaving soap.
  • Price may seem a bit on the higher side for most users out there.
  • It may not fit into all types of shaving bowls.

2. Proraso Shaving Soap in a Bowl, Sensitive Skin, 5.2 oz (150 ml)

Proraso-Shaving-Soap-in-a-BowlProraso has been making shaving into a pleasing daily job for over 3 centuries now. This is a shaving soap brand based in Italy which delivers satisfaction to customers all over the world.

This will prove to be the top shaving soap for men who have sensitive skin. As it happens, I have used it for six months on the trot before switching to Henry Cavendish Himalaya that I spoke of earlier.

In the past, I couldn’t use all kinds of shaving materials without suffering skin rashes and irritation. But Proraso has prepared this shaving soap in a bowl with the natural based formulation and does not use any mineral oil or artificial colors. This prompted me to reach out for this product and I don’t regret using it for six months one bit!

This soap contains various natural ingredients such as coconut oil, glycerin, menthol, Thymus vulgaris (Thyme) Flower/Leaf Extract, Avena sativa (Oat) Kernel Extract, Camellia sinensis Leaf Extract and more.

All these natural ingredients help your skin in various ways.

For instance, Oatmeal Extract provides a softening and soothing effect which is favorable for maintaining the skin’s pH value. Green Tea (Camellia sinensis) extract is a natural antioxidant; plus, it is rich in polyphenols and minerals.

Owing to the presence of these ingredients, the shaving soap helps to moisturize the skin and protect it from irritation. The soap does not contain any silicone or parabens. Parabens are widely used preservatives in cosmetic and pharmaceutical products.

They are known to cause allergic reactions and may also cause breast cancer (though there is no scientific proof till date).

However, the main benefit of using this soap is the creamy lather. This lather softens the skin and the facial hair so that you can get a close shave with smooth results.

A pro tip: Apply a top-notch pre-shave oil just to get that extra boost in skin care.

  • This thing goes well with the wet shaving machines.
  • You don’t have to rub it for extended period to produce lather. It does that in quick time.
  • Ingredients like “Green Tea” and “Oatmeal” revitalize your skin and keep you fresh.
  • Users with sensitive skin can find reliable solution in this shaving soap that reduces itchy feeling.
  • I’d not advise you to use this thing with chrome razors as it would do a number on those things.
  • This thing is small and size and doesn’t last all that long as other products do.

3. Col. Conk Shave Soap 2.25 Ounces (Variety 4 Pack)

If you are a fan of old school, you will surely like the Colonel Conk 4 pack shaving soap. Col. Conk has been manufacturing these things for over 150 years. And in all this time, they have been successful in maintaining their quality and performance.

This pack of 4 contains 4 shaving soaps. Each of the soaps is of 2.25 oz quantity and they each have a distinct fragrance. The fragrances are Bay Rum, Lime, Amber, and Almond. The scent feels fresh while shaving and leaves a pleasant after-scent after every shave.

The four soaps come in plastic, lidded cups. This makes it easy to use them compared to many other shaving soaps which require extra dishes. However, you also take the soaps out and put in a separate dish if you feel like it.

The soaps are gentle to the skin and do not cause any irritation. They provide a mild feel and smooth results. Co. Conk shaving soaps produce a rich and thick lather that is crucial for a close shave.

The lather softens the skin and the hairs so that shaving becomes quick and frictionless. I used to soak the soap in cold water for 5-10 minutes or use warm water – whichever suited me at that time.

Some people prefer microwaving the soap in a separate cup and use it from there. As shaving soaps go, it is ideal to use a brush to apply and lather on your skin for best results. Lastly, this pack of 4 varieties of soaps is a cost-effective purchase.

  • Comes with four different soaps so that you are never “Out of Options” when using one.
  • I liked the fact that I got to use 5 ounces of cream with every pack I bought.
  • If you have a brush, you will love using this shaving soap like me.
  • Forget shaving bowls, you don’t even need one to use this thing.
  • This shaving soap is manufactured and packaged in the USA.
  • If you are using an aftershave, the fragrance cancels out that of the aftershave.
  • Some shaving soap review writers found discrepancies in performance of this thing.

4. Lather & Wood Shaving Tallow Dense Leather Shaving Soap, Barbershop, 4.7-Ounce

Lather & Wood-Shaving-Tallow-Dense-Leather-Shaving-SoapDo you like the scent of the lather you found in the old barbershops? If you do, you will also like the Lather & Wood Dense Shaving Soap. This is a professional grade product, now used and liked by many people in their homes. This is 4.7 oz pack and will last for months, even with regular use.

It’s as if you will be spending only pennies per day for every shave. It is the ideal shaving soap for anyone who likes and enjoys wet shaving. Use a good quality brush and any kind of razor you prefer and you will be greatly satisfied with the results.

The key ingredients of this shaving soap are Tallow and Shea Butter much like the first product on my list today. They help to create a lot of dense and slippery lather. Plus, they moisturize your skin and keep it safe from irritation.

Furthermore, this shaving soap has a delicate scent with a masculine feel, which lingers subtly for hours after your every shaving session.

There are two ways in which you can use this Lather & Wood Barbershop shaving soap. You can dip a shaving brush in warm water and add a little bit of soap on it. Then swirl the brush in a bowl to form a dense lather in only a few minutes. Now apply the lather on your face and enjoy the gentle feel.

The lather is long lasting and so it will stay in form even after an hour of making it. One other way of using the soap is directly forming the lather on your face. Both of the ways are effective.

Just to make sure you always get the best shaving soap for use, manufacturers produce this product in small quantities. This way, they can devote much of their time in making few quality products. You always get the quality you strive for.

  • I can guarantee you that this product is handmade and delivered to customers in small batches for quality assurance!
  • Once again, Shea butter and tallow provide your skin a nice tone and smooth texture.
  • This product is one that lasts long and I am talking about three to four months.
  • You can use Lather & Wood Shaving Tallow for commercial establishments; it beats other commercial products in quality.
  • Manufacturers can improve on the texture of the lather.

5. The Blades Grim Gold Luxury Shaving Soap, "Smolder"

The-Blades-Grim-Gold-Luxury-Shaving-SoapDon’t get scared from the name. The Blades Grim is not as grim as it may sound like. This brand of shaving soap manufacturers has been satisfying men’s shaving needs since 2014 (the year they were established).

This is a USA based brand that is known for their handmade shaving soaps like the Gold Luxury Shaving Soap. They have used coconut oil and glycerin along with other natural ingredients. The benefit of coconut oil and glycerin is that they moisturize and nourishes the skin leaving it smooth and oil free.

Although it is already moderately priced, after using the shave for the first time you will agree it is totally worth every penny. Having a tough time believing me? Just read all the shaving soap review articles posted online and you’ll find out!

This The Blades Grim soap is a 4-ounce soap that comes in a golden tin box. One key feature of this shaving soap is the Smolder scent. The name is not enough to demonstrate how Smolder actually smells like.

However, from the ingredients used for this scent will help you to get an abstract idea. You will get a hint of gourmand vanilla, notes of citrus, orange peel, mandarin, coriander leaves, star anise and Venezuela Tonka. All these ingredients together provide a clean and fresh yet warm and toasty scent.

So you can understand Smolder is actually an umbrella term for a mixture of these ingredients. With rich, dense lather, effortless razor glide, smooth skin, and a Smolder scent.

The Blades Grim has been able to manufacture a mysteriously luxurious shaving soap. If you want a taste of this mystery, buy one today.

  • I am a fan of this product’s smell.
  • Compared to others, this one lathes pretty easily.
  • Sleek design makes this a perfect addition for a stylish shaving counter in your bathroom.
  • This thing provides you a consistent performance all the time.
  • Some shaving soap review writers found it containing too much water for their convenience.

How did I Make the Selections?

I’d be lying if I said, “I responded to a hunch and came up with these products.”

No. I didn’t. I did my research pretty well. Plus, I am a regular user of a shaving soap brand myself.

Quite naturally, I considered multiple aspects before I actually made my choices clear on these things.

What are those? Let us find out.

My Selections HAD TO PASS the “Natural Ingredients” Test

Yes, I did check if the products are made using natural ingredients that you find around your environment before I put them on my list. I am a bit skeptical about shaving soaps that use chemicals.

These things (the chemicals) trigger skin irritation, red spots on your face, and burns more often than not. Sure, using natural ingredients elevates the cost of your product. But if we want the best shaving soap out there that complements our skin and soothes it, shedding some extra bucks is acceptable.

I Have a Sensitive Skin – I Had to be Double Assured

Although These things on my list are from natural ingredients that don’t trigger burns or irritations, I had to be extra careful about what’s going to be the ideal shaving soap for me. A man like me who has sensitive skin can be paranoid sometimes you see!

After going through dozens of Shaving Soap Reviews and watching some tests done of these things on YouTube, I finally found out that the products of my choice don’t contain elements like Alcohol or Parabens. These are the ingredients that soak up water and moisture from your body at a rapid rate.

Don’t worry, only after assuring myself, I am recommending you such fine products.

How Exactly Will the Top Shaving Soaps Counter Dryness?

That is the second question I asked myself. I have used two or three products on my list. I compared them concerning performance against dryness. Amazingly, these products produced a thick lather that stayed the whole course of shaving.

If you are worried about itchy skin and stubborn hair on your face that is too hard, the lather from these soaps will soften the hair to a point that you can shave it off pretty easily.

I can understand people being skeptical about leaning on shaving soaps to counter dryness. For the picky shavers, I’ve got my own list of Best Shaving Gels that Money can help you buy.

Will I be Able to Use These with My Shaving Brush?

This is the question that lingered on my mind when I compiled the list. Mainly because I didn’t want to leave my favorite brush behind.

If you are a big fan of wet shaving, you’ll love these soaps as they sync so very well with your brushes without compromising the integrity and lather quality. Personally, I use a badger brush to take care of the job. But you can go in with any type of brush you like.

Will My Soap Moisturize My Skin Properly?

You might not realize this but moisture is absolutely necessary for your skin. In many ways, conventional shaving accessories leave you high and dry when you are done with the shaving. You can feel bumps and red spots on the areas where you just shaved.

But not with these products on my list. All of these products feature moisturizers as ingredients. Some of these even come with a pack of moisturizer separately. Applying these will make sure that your skin remains soft even after hours of your shaving routine.

I Considered the Quality of the Lather These Things Provide

Since I have my own experience of using these products, I can vouch for the lather quality. Yet, I checked and double checked with shaving soap reviewers to see if they had the same experience as me.

As it turns out, all the products maintain more than decent quality as far as lather is concerned. You just need to whip the soap and apply it using the shaving brush. The soap will turn into a creamy substance that will soften the beard or mustache and provide a nice scent that will stay long after you completed your shaving routine in the morning.

The lather of these soaps does a good job hydrating your dry skin too!

Why Did I Choose Shaving Soaps and Not Shaving Creams or Gels?

Valid question. Shaving Creams and Gels can certainly be helpful in the act of shaving. But I had to go for shaving soaps and I had my reasons for doing so too. What are they? Let’s find out.

The primary focus of my consideration for soaps instead of creams or gels is the fact that I preferred wet shaving conditions for this article.

When it comes to wet shaving, you must maintain a good balance between the lather, your shaving razor, and of course, the skin. You need to align all three in a straight line to work in synchronization.

When I say “Lather,” that is where the best of shaving creams and shaving gels fall short. You NEED rich, creamy, and soft lather to get the job done. That is where none but a heated shaving soap comes in.

Plus, you have the price point. These soaps are cheaper than a whole setup of gels or shaving creams. I really liked how quickly I could apply these things on my face and got the results I was expecting as well.

Last Passage of Play before I Finish Up!

Phew! Finally, I am done with my article on Best shaving soap choices. It was a humongous task mind you. I had to test each one for days and compile all the findings here. After going through shaving soap review articles on the internet and comparing mine with theirs, I can certainly say I’ve put no food wrong in the choices I’ve made.

These products will help you overcome skin sensitivity problems after cleanup. These are totally free of the chemicals we all dread in our skin products. Also, the rich lather these things produce will give you a feel of class and luxury!

I dare say, “You won’t spend a dime wrong if you buy one of these on my list today.”

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: