Best Bay Rum Aftershave Reviews – The Smell of a True Gentlemen

If you happen to be one of those people that shave on a daily basis, then there is nothing more important than having a nice and refreshing aftershave balm. Some of the best aftershaves are equally important as the shaving cream and razor quality.

Anyhow, we are here today to discuss some of the best bay rum aftershave products on the market. With a good bay rum aftershave you will be able to hydrate your skin properly. Simply put, there is nothing better than putting a nice, clean, and quality aftershave on your face.

With the West Indies bay leaf, Jamaican rum, and lots of spices, a bay rum aftershave is currently one of the most popular choices for men all over the world.

Best Bay Rum Aftershave – Comparison Table

Bay Rum Aftershave SplashNatural and premium ingredients4 oz9/10
GABELS Bay RumNatural ingredients with essential oils and alcohol16 oz8/10
Genuine OgallalaNatural ingredients mixed with a few chemicals8 oz8/10
Captain's Choice Natural ingredients with: Alcohol, Witch Hazel, Essential Oils and Extracts, Glycerin4 oz7/10
Master Bay RumNatural ingredients with essential oils and leaves15 oz7/10

Top 5 bay rum aftershave reviews

Before we start reviewing our selected products, it is quite important to know that all of these aftershaves are quite special. They all have something unique and they bring some of the best ‘’men’’ smell into your lives. Now, let’s see exactly what have we prepared in this bay rum aftershave review. Let’s begin.

Bay Rum Aftershave Splash for Men

Bay-Rum-Aftershave-Splash-for-MenOur first and possibly the best bay rum aftershave is Barberry Coast bay rum aftershave. This amazing aftershave is made out of the natural and premium ingredients which were handcrafted into specially formulated balm.

One of the things that separate this aftershave from others is the fact that this one is filtered and aged. This means that you will get only the highest-quality product as your aftershave product. Simply, this aftershave is made to be perfect for every man.

Next, this aftershave is totally safe and healthy for your skin. Namely, it is made out of the natural exotic spices and citrus, essential oils, and a little bit of essence of bay leaves. Also, there are no chemicals or artificial colors, as well as the parafen.

The main benefit of using this aftershave is its ability to awaken your senses instantly. Simply speaking, you will feel light manly burn that will quickly go away and leave you with toned and refreshed skin.

All in all, this aftershave is going to take good care of your skin which will be noticeable for sure. Also, the scent is just amazing and it provides a nice manly look.

Pros and highlights:

  • Premium and natural ingredients
  • Filtered and great for your skin tone
  • Refreshes your skin after every use
  • Provides a real manly look and smell

Cons and potential flaws:

  • Scent is going to last for only a couple of hours
  • You need to apply it carefully in order not to spill it

GABELS Bay Rum After Shave Lotion

GABELS-Bay-Rum-After-Shave-LotionGABELS Bay Rum Aftershave Lotion is one of the most popular aftershave lotions when it comes to bay rum aroma and scent. Namely, this aftershave is made out of the natural ingredients with a little bit of glycerin and alcohol.

Anyhow, the main benefit of this aftershave is that it leaves a nice and brisk feeling on your face after you apply it. Also, it will quickly calm and hydrate your skin and leave it in a good tone and scent for hours.

However, there are some aftershaves that will burn you in the beginning. Well, this one is not, even though it contains alcohol and glycerin which are known to be quite strong on a freshly shaved face.

Next, the ability to refresh your skin after every use is just something that you can expect from this aftershave. If you had some serious cut or just a minor razor burn, this aftershave will be the perfect solution since it nourishes the skin properly.

Also, the main thing about this aftershave is the smell that lasts for hours. Namely, if you shave in the morning, the smell will follow you through the whole day. This is something that I recommend for real men in a business class.

To top things off, this aftershave comes in a convenient bottle that can be carried everywhere. You can basically put it in any bag or even in the suit.

Pros and highlights:

  • Nourishes your skin against razor burn
  • Refreshing and hydrating formula
  • Lasts long and never loses scent strength
  • Great for businessmen and gentlemen

Cons and potential flaws:

  • Has a bit strong clove smell which is not convenient for everyone
  • The opening cap might get tilted from time to time

Ogallala Bay Rum Regular

Ogallala-Bay-Rum-RegularGenuine Ogallala Bay Rum Regular aftershave is specially formulated aftershave that will provide a cool and refreshing feeling on your skin. For the most of the people that use this aftershave, it is quite good for getting rid of the inflammation and razor burns.

Anyhow, the natural ingredients that were used in order to make this aftershave are only boosting its quality and value. Also, this aftershave is quite good and healthy for your skin, especially if you have a bit more sensitive skin.

However, the scent and the smell that this aftershave deliver is going to bring you back in the 19 century where cowboys where the real thing. You can surely feel the difference and you will know what real men used to smell like back in time.

Next, the ability to nourish your skin and to provide a nice tone for your skin is also something that this aftershave offers. Namely, you will be surprised when you apply it for the first time.

As for the smell, I recommend judging it after you apply it, since there is a different note of smell that comes from the bottle. This means that you will feel the full experience of a great aftershave after a couple of uses.

All in all, this aftershave is quite good for the price and it offers something truly special when it comes to scent and smell. One more thing, ladies absolutely love it and they admire the man that wears this note of smell and scent.

Pros and highlights:

  • Made out of the natural ingredients without any chemicals
  • Provides long-lasting smell of a true man
  • Great for bay rum lovers with sensitive skin
  • Nourishes and refreshes the skin

Cons and potential flaws:

  • You need to shake the bottle before applying it every time
  • The bottle might get slippery after some time, so you need to be careful not to drop it

Captain’s Choice Original Bay Rum

Captain's-Choice-Original-Bay-RumCaptain’s Choice Original Bay Rum is truly one of the top bay rum aftershave products on the market. Simply speaking, this aftershave is quite capable of delivering some of the best after shave experience.

First, the skin will be nourished and refreshed after only couple of times use. Also, you can expect this aftershave to provide such elegant tone for your skin which is really important if you want to impress someone.

Anyhow, the natural ingredients in a combination with essential oils and alcohol are quite good for lots of things. The main benefit of using this aftershave is actually the smell and scent that it provides.

Since there are no chemicals or any other thing like that, this aftershave smells absolutely wonderful and authentic. Simply, you will hardly find something this great when it comes to best bay rum aftershave models.

Also, the bottle is quite authentic as well and it looks like a 19 century bottle of aftershave. With the dark brown colors in a combination with black cap and label, this aftershave surely will look good in your collection.

In conclusion, this one is simply one of the most convenient aftershaves if you look for authentic scent that lasts for long.

Pros and highlights:

  • Made out of the combination of premium natural ingredients
  • Solid and great for skin toning
  • Leaves strong and authentic smell that lasts for hours
  • Instantly refreshes your skin and gets rid of the inflammation

Cons and potential flaws:

  • This aftershave is quite thick and applying requires a bit more time
  • You need to shake the bottle before every use in order to get the best quality

Master Bay Rum After Shave

Master-Bay-Rum-After-ShaveMaster Bay Rum Aftershave is definitely the aftershave that will offer some quite different and authentic smell and experience. Namely, the formula that contains only natural ingredients is quite good when it comes to skin nourishing and refreshing.

The first thing that you should notice about this aftershave is its ability to calm and hydrate the skin after every shave. As we all know, there are some razors that simply leave burns and cuts, and therefore, this aftershave will quickly get rid of the inflammation and razor burn.

Second, the skin tone that this aftershave leaves on your face is a bit darker and provides serious and elegant look. I strongly recommend using this aftershave if you need to look sharp and classy on your job.

Next, the amazingly strong scent will ensure that you get noticed and admired. Simply put, the smell will last long and it surely offers quite good scent.

Anyhow, if you like having an aftershave that takes care of your skin and offers some strongly men scent and tone, then this one is just for you.

Pros and highlights:

  • Full with high-quality natural ingredients
  • Offers quite strong and long-lasting smell
  • Nourishes and protects your skin against razor burn
  • Hydrating your skin while bringing great skin tone

Cons and potential flaws:

  • The scent might wear off if you don’t apply the right amount
  • Sometimes this aftershave is a bit hard to apply since it requires you to rub your face a couple of times

What makes Bay Rum Aftershave better than the rest?

Now, we are going to discuss some of the main benefits of bay rum aftershave. Simply put, let’s see exactly why this aftershave type is so great and better than rest of the aftershaves.

Authentic smell

First and possibly the biggest benefit of bay rum aftershaves is that they have such strong and authentic scent. Namely, they are made out of the bay leaves and some spices that offer great smell that lasts for long period of time.

Also, the fact that this aftershave type is commonly used by true and elegant men is telling a lot about this aftershave. Some men even use it without even shaving at all, they just love the smell and the feeling this aftershave is capable of providing.

Skin tone

The fact that bay rum aftershaves offer a bit darker skin tone has truly made them famous among lots of men. Their ingredients are quite exotic and ‘’wild’’ and therefore, they offer a bit darker skin tone that perfect for getting a serious and sharp look.

Most of the businessmen use this type of aftershave just in order to look great which their jobs require a lot.


In the light of everything we said about best bay rum aftershave products, it is quite easy to see that these aftershaves are perfect for every serious man. If you plan on looking and smelling like true gentlemen or classy businessmen, than I recommend using bay rum aftershaves.

Now, it is only up to you to decide which one to get since they are all good in their own way.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: